EU tax measures should encourage switch from smoking to safer alternatives for public health
People who have quit smoking by switching to safer nicotine products, scientists and public health experts are calling on the EU Commission to take a risk-proportionate approach to tobacco and nicotine taxes in support of public health.
Europe’s smoking rate remains very high, with 24% of the overall adult population continuing to use combustible tobacco. The European Tobacco Harm Reduction Advocates (ETHRA), a consortium of 24 grassroots associations across 17 European countries, represents 27 million European consumers who use nicotine pouches, vapes, snus and heated tobacco products as safer alternatives to combustible tobacco.
ETHRA was deeply concerned about the potential impact of comments made during an EU Commission subcommittee on tax on February 6th, 2025. Commissioner Wopke Hoekstra (Climate, Net Zero, Clean Growth and Taxation) said “Smoking kills, vaping kills.” This is simply untrue. Vaping – and other safer nicotine products – all pose significantly lower risks to health than continued use of combustible cigarettes.
Before the EU Commission leadership met to discuss the revision of the Tobacco Excise Directive in April 2024, ETHRA wrote to Commissioners to express frustration over the sharing of inaccurate information or opinion by senior EU policymakers – and concerns over reports that the Commission plans to increase taxes on safer nicotine products. The letter has now gained signatories from multiple scientists and public health experts from numerous member states.
If safer alternatives to smoking are made more expensive, less appealing and less available, the goal of a tobacco-free Europe by 2040 will not be reached. Every year, 700,000 people lose their lives to smoking-related diseases in Europe. Tobacco harm reduction offers the EU an opportunity to dramatically reduce that toll.
On 12 May, following a meeting about climate change, Commissioner Hoekstra commented on X: “I cannot stress enough the importance on science informing our policy-making in these times of disinformation.” ETHRA agrees, and invites Commissioner Hoekstra to engage with the science, not media sensationalism, about tobacco harm reduction.
Read our letter, co-signed by independent experts, here