- Details
On Tuesday 10 November we wrote to the Directorates-General (DGs) of the European Commission to voice our serious concerns about the revision of the EU's tobacco and nicotine legislation. In the letter we included our submission to the 18 May to 15 June 2026 Call for Evidence and our critique of the Public Consultation questionnaire. The letter is copied below.
On behalf of European Tobacco Harm Reduction Advocates (ETHRA), we are writing to express our serious concerns regarding the ongoing revision of the Tobacco Products and Tobacco Advertising Directives.
Attached is our submission to the European Commission's Call for Evidence, which also includes a detailed critique of the Public Consultation questionnaire.
Our concerns extend beyond individual policy proposals to the integrity of the consultation process itself. The questionnaire repeatedly fails to distinguish between combustible tobacco products and low-risk alternatives, restricts respondents' ability to express evidence-based, nuanced views, and fails to adequately consider the unintended consequences of restrictive policies. These shortcomings risk producing a misleading picture of public opinion and undermining the credibility of the consultation.
Our submission also presents substantial evidence that excessively restrictive regulation can discourage smokers from switching to low-risk alternatives, encourage a return to smoking, and fuel illicit markets. These are not merely theoretical concerns, but consequences already being observed in jurisdictions pursuing such policies.
We are equally concerned by misleading statements originating from within the Commission that suggest smoke-free nicotine products carry risks comparable to cigarettes. Our submission addresses these claims and includes a letter signed by 23 European experts challenging their scientific basis.
It is also not clear to us how the Commission is treating the voice of nearly 124,000 citizens, experts, and other affected stakeholders who raised many concerns in the context of the Call for Evidence and Open Public Consultation. The Commission’s own summary report of the OPC also selectively prioritises data from Civil Society Organizations and Authorities, which account for approximately 170 out of nearly 43,000 submissions.
With approximately 700,000 smoking-related deaths annually in the EU, the consequences of regulatory decisions that fail to distinguish between products according to their risks could be severe.
We urge you to ensure that these concerns are properly addressed, that the evidence of unintended consequences is fully considered in the impact assessment, and that consumers, as those directly affected by these decisions, are meaningfully represented throughout the legislative review process.
Kind regards,
Damian Sweeney
On behalf of ETHRA & partners
www.ethra.co
- Details

ETHRA’s October roundup of news: TPD3 developments - Tobacco Tax Directive negotiations fail - eight EU ministers call for further nicotine restrictions - country updates from across Europe - Ireland's vaping legislation - new research on smoking cessation and nicotine pouches - and finally, a look at nicotine regulation and public perceptions. Read on for more.
- Details
This article has been authored by Stefaan Hendrickx and Frank Baeyens, public health and scientific partners at ETHRA.
Why the ban on the sale of nicotine pouches is harmful to public health
An inexperienced student with no nicotine dependence ingests a heavy dose of nicotine at the request of the programme makers. He then describes, whilst retching, the resulting symptoms of poisoning. The Pano-report on nicotine pouches, recently broadcast on Flemish television (29 October), resolutely opted for sensationalism and fearmongering. A predetermined media narrative was selectively constructed through cherry-picking and confirmation bias. Harm reduction was dismissed in the report as nothing more than a commercial ploy by the tobacco industry. This was a missed opportunity for journalistic clarification, because, just like snus, nicotine pouches do indeed offer prospects for public health. This issue calls for nuance, not a blunt approach.
Read more: Why the ban on the sale of nicotine pouches is harmful to public health
- Details
ETHRA is delighted to welcome our newest public health partner, Stefaan Hendrickx, who has authored the following article on youth use of nicotine products in Flanders.
Comments on the results of a new study regarding nicotine use among Flemish youth
Summary
- Shift in consumption: overall nicotine use among Flemish youth remains stable at 24.3%, but a major shift has occurred: exclusive tobacco smoking has dropped to a historic low, while e-cigarettes and dual use have become the dominant patterns.
- Misleading metrics: the heavy focus on "past-year use" in the report and media dramatizes the situation, failing to reflect that much of this behavior is temporary adolescent experimentation rather than chronic addiction.
- Positive trends ignored: traditional tobacco smoking is at an all-time low, also in vocational education, which consistently has the highest number of smokers, yet this public health success is not being celebrated.
- Information gap: Flemish youth and professionals that work with youth are intentionally left uninformed about the relative risks between smoking and vaping, as well as the differences between legal and illegal markets.
Read more: Comments on a new study regarding nicotine use among Flemish youth
- EU Tobacco Consultation: Citizens Have Spoken
- ETHRA September news roundup
- Impossible by design: the EU survey on future tobacco and nicotine policy
- ETHRA May & June news roundup
- The EU survey - sample answers and reasoning
- ETHRA April news roundup
- EU Commission TPD Evaluation Report
- Urgent appeal against any significant tax increases for safer nicotine products
- ETHRA March news roundup
- ETHRA February news roundup
- ETHRA December and January news roundup
- ETHRA November news roundup
- ETHRA October news roundup
- ETHRA September news roundup
- ETHRA Summer news roundup
- Tobacco Excise Directive Impact Assessment
- ETHRA May news roundup
- Scientific and public health experts support consumer position on tobacco taxation
- Letter to Health Commissioner Varhelyi regarding vapes and 'popcorn lung'
- ETHRA April news roundup